Shay McCartan

@Silverbantam, can you take a call, it's for you.

 

Was better in the last few home games that I saw which is more than can be said for a lot of the others. Whether that'd be enough for Edin to want to keep him who knows. Maybe not if he has moved away.

 

Maybe a return to Accrington?

 

His instagram still says Saltaire.

 

Probably just spent the summer over there

 

Tranmere?

 

He strikes me as the type that wouldn’t think twice about blobbing from training if he couldn’t be arsed. Seen nothing in the lad at all to suggest he’s even a conference player

 

Be a good bit of business if we could get our money back on him. Weren’t Luton keen on him back in January?

 

Definitely a confidence player

 

Back to League Two. This was too much.

 

Question:

If it's so, so, so vital that we get our money back for Wyke, surely we need to make up some of the huge waste of a fee on Shay?

 

I am hoping Shay is here and gets an extended run

 

Where and how would you fit him in the team?

 

If they with two upfront I would us him as second striker or on the right in a three. I also thought he did well in the last match playing on the right wing

 

On the right in a 3? Jones or McCartan?
Jones for me if no other options.

 

The only role is see for him is either a strike partner in a front two or just behind a lone striker. Doesn't have the vision for a Billy Clarke type role but looks more comfortable running with the ball.

 

Along with Poleon, would be looking to offload McCartan personally. Would have to take a hit on the transfer fee, but so be it. I'm afraid the lad looks out of his depth at this club and level

 

Not if we're playing three centre backs, or we'd be the most open team on the face of the Earth

 

Seriously, how can any City fan rate this lad?

For us he has been shit£.

He joined looking like he was unfit and downhill since then.

Sell him!