Charlton match thread - 15 Sept

look so from where i sit but think main stand at that end would have had a better view

 

I'm guessing Parker can just ask Killgallon what happened since he printed his open letter.

Fans don't need to know every detail of what goes on behind the scenes and shouldn't expect it. Publicising private fall outs is extremely unprofessional.

 

If edin CAN keep his promise to David, don't think this will happen. I am still positive Michael would like to have at least included Killa in our squad, or are you Edin worshipers saying the squad was too strong for him.

 

I am not remotely interested in what goes on behind the scenes as long as it doesn’t spill out onto the pitch. Then I do want to know some of the decision making, this is the club that I support, and I want it to continue to be competitive not a training ground for older school boys. I also want our maximum budget spent on quality signings. I don’t want to be lied to or treated like a mushroom. So if this is uncomfortable for the owners tough, I will still be here when they are enjoying their millions elsewhere.

 

"Edin worshippers" really? If I didn't know you were a silver surfer I'd tell you to grow up.

 

It also applies the other way @Nick_W_ where because some disagree with things Edin has done are called Edin hatters, I personally wish we were only talking football but unfortunately because of a massive mistake by Edin which many pointed out when he hired Micheal Collins was a very poor decision.

 

I agree, just stupid labels.

 

Looked like a penalty from NW corner.

 

I think he will do which at least gives us hope. However, I do feel he is limited to what he will be able to achieve with such a young and bare squad. Let's see what position we are in and what backing he receives by the end of January.

 

In the Herald newspaper of 12th September

In the Herald newspaper of 12th September Hamilton manager,Martin Canning states " All summer I was looking for a sterotypical dominant British centre back with experience who can talk, organise and help younger players as well.
Matt was in the mould and we were speaking to him for over a month....."

 

The more I think a

Payne reminds me of Billy Knott. Undoubted talent but poor decision making.

 

You are a mushroom. Business gets done....and should be done.....in private. Why a manager picks one player over another is literally nothing to do with the fans if it's for anything other than footballing reasons.

To me the privacy of the dressing room is sacrosanct. Once people start leaking what goes on in there - whether it's managers or players - then the game is up.

 

You might want to have a word with Man City and Amazon then regarding their behind the scenes TV series. Tv cameras in the dressing room all season for that one.

 

Unfortunately people got used to the previous owners sharing everything, usually when talking about deficits etc.

 

I wonder how much control Man City had over the final cut.

Sunderland did it as well, was it Peter Reid?

 

I'm pretty sure they don't show everything.

 

I never said they did, but they show behind the scenes. You said the changing rooms are private, 'sacrosanct'. It seems Man City don't agree with that. I happen to agree with the general gist of your comment but as fans we want to know whats going on at our club, its part of human nature to be curious.

 

I can’t believe anyone in this day and age that customers/fans are kept in the dark and fed on bullshit!! If they want fans to be oblivious to the comings and goings of a football club, run it in the right manner. I can see we are not going to get on this subject.