Charlton match thread - 15 Sept

You know you cant have it both ways. One minute Edin is interferring with team selection and he is slated for it. The next minute he should jump in and overrule the head coaches decision not to involve a player in his 1st team plans. Which do you all want ?

 

Because Collins was even more clueless than Rahic, and Rahic knew he was getting rid of Collins

 

Theres a pattern amongst the posters when it comes to Edin Rahic, you can tell by the posts and the likes attributed to those posts, the same one ‘like’ the same posts.
I guess whatever you think of Rahic isn’t going to have been swayed by the ‘apology’ put out the other day, one way or another.

 

So back to the match, watching in iFollow , should we have had a penalty in the second half when McGowan was sent to the floor? No replays on iFollow, but Jonesy seemed to think it was?

 

Please explain what you mean, because I’m lost. However, you are the most likely candidate to back up my post, so I look forward to your reply.

 

He didnt know he was getting of Collins from pre-season did he when the coaching staff decided from the off they didnt even want to put Killa on the bench.

 

ive only been to 2 matches this year as i’ve been ill but i thought they played okmyeaterday and hope that Hopkin will get them back on track

 

Sorry. Didn't realise

 

Which post is that?

 

Quite apt seeing as I'd had zero sleep due to young kids and you got the wrath of my grumpiness

 

No need for an apology we've all made similar mistakes, that was the first thing I did when I heard we'd signed Doyle, google the lad Davies to see if he was a free, but Mansfield had already signed him up.

 

That's because he doesn't release the ball for the strikers to have a chance of scoring. He lost the ball that lead to Charltons first goal and also lost it several times which broke down many of our attacks. There's no doubting he has talent but at the moment we need a team player not an individual player that creates chances for our strikers and not just for himself.

 

Obviously the one I quoted?

 

Totally agree, there were quite a few times where he could have played others in and didn't. No doubt he's a good player but has to know when to pass the ball.

 

That doesn’t tell anything now does it?

 

But why? and why did Collins lie about it?

 

Isn't the simplest reason that you don't air your dirty laundry in public?

Parker is the one who said it was Collins decision. Given how willing he's been to criticise Rahic recently I don't see any reason why he'd publicly swim against the tide on this decision unless he had good reason to think it was true.

 

Lying to the fans is dirty laundry! If we are to believe Rahic, Collins was not only useless, but a liar as well? I don’t blame Parker how is he supposed to work out who is telling the truth. All I know is that we a great defender, and would no doubt have pulled that defence together and now we don’t! Along with appointing a coach who was not up to the job, and a liar, who got rid of said defender. Didn’t prepare the team properly during the pre season costing us dearly, and may yet cost us our league status.