O'Donnell or Wilson?

O'Donnell without question. Yes he's made mistakes but so does every keeper and he's made tonnes of saves to keep us in games throughout the season. He seems to be a player lacking confidence in those infront of him and you can't blame him really.

Plus we haven't had a keeper coach for god knows how long so that hasn't exactly helped.

 

Is this really up for debate ?

 

Not very good but best option

 

We should recruit a gk coach to work on the errors but finances have dictated otherwise....thanks to Mr Rahic

 

Now is not the time to be bringing in a relatively inexperienced keeper.

O,'Donnell has made a couple of errors lately that have led to goals
However, lets be honest, he must be a nervous wreck playing behind our brittle defence

So, no brainer for me, stick with O'Donnell

 

Didn't we have a thread like this about Doyle......... Look what happened then.

 

What a strange thread

 

Was Wilson the goalkeeper that played against Peterborough in the cup. If so then I thought he was awful in that game. Spent half the game miles off his line and we conceded from the halfway line because of it. O Donnell hasn't been great lately but I definitely wasnt impressed in the only game I've seen Wilson play

 

Remember when Rouven needed his chance because Doyle kept making errors, and Doyle was considered a mediocre keeper?

Just saying.

 

In O'Donnells defence if we let every team having 50 shots on target every game there is a chance he will make mistakes.

 

Made the most saves in the top 4 divisions, but yeah drop him for someone with their own bloopers vid on YouTube.

 

If anyone thinks Wilson is better than O'Donnell need to give their head a wobble

 

O'D is that great but he will do.

I would be nervous with O'Connor losing his man all the time and getting dragged.

Chicksen being shi&e

NKP just not showing up.

Wilson should be number 3.

 

Rouven. Aww bless him. Absolute shocker, despite flinging himself about like a rag doll. Total comedy performance. I bet they didn't ask him to get the drinks from the bar during the infamous, "family photo" evening which Edin hated (and probably had on his wall, black marking crosses over each one as and when).

 

Pleased to see the voting is as it is.

Too often in the past it's been a case of wanting the players playing week in, week out to lose their place, with the guy doing absolutely nothing for the club getting bigged up as worthy of that place.

Earn your spot, end of.

If you're the best in every single training session, it's only a matter of time.

 

Wilson is shocking watched him at Peterborough fa cup game would rather put the young keeper in than him o donnell is a good keeper just lacking confidence

 

We need another good goalie then, add that to the shopping list.