Current loan players. Who would you like to see back at VP next season

Yeah. At this stage its got to be all about going up, not developing players for next year. Although having said that Kelly looked ok in the few minutes we saw him

 

Even Andy Kiyomya has spotted it so it must be bleeding obvious. Show Banks the outside and he's fecked. If he can't come inside all he is able to do is pass back to Halliday. Have we got a right footed winger? That'll fox 'em.

 

I wouldn't be bringing any back. The only loan player who's really had an impact was Wright - who I'd love to see back here.

Bola has hardly played and looked poor when he has - very strange signing.
Crichlow has done well but I'd like to see Kelly have more of an opportunity as the main back up to Stubbs.
Perreira has been a waste of time.
Costelloe is one of the worst players I've seen in a city shirt.
Nevers - I'd forgotten he was even here.

We need to be much more effective in the loan market. He probably won't be back in L2 next season, but someone like that lad Kemp at Hartlepool is what we need to be brining in. Next seasons squad needs to be a little smaller and bigger on attacking quality.

 

Kian Harratt ?

 

John Hendrie, wake up man!

 

On yesterdays one legged showing Banks ….bye bye.

 

Certainly looks shot of confidence. Was really expecting him to kick on after the performance and goal against Colchester but sadly he’s almost gone the other way. A bit similar to Chapman though, there’s literally Andy Cook to aim for when moving forwards so unless you’ve got the ability of Messi to dance past the opposition, you’re not standing a great chance…..

 

Yes agree, I posted earlier his best game in a City shirt , but you cannot deny I was right after his recent showing before today. Two shots today again were ridiculously poor though, but I’ll give him them!

 

Banks was good today and clearly has talent otherwise you don't get a contract at Palace, yes he's raw and incosistent but end of the day he's a very young lad a long way from home so it can't be easy, I get frustrated fans getting on his back for any poor performance fair enough, but in his defence he usually gets stick for his attacking play being non productive but he keeps trying to create and doesn't resort to just passing back to a centre back. I think given time and support he could become a very good L1/L2 player.

 

Closer to home with us than he is at Palace

 

Ah yes fair enough just googled to see he's Scottish formerly with Dundee Utd and Clyde

 

Cost Palace £500,000 apparently, not sure if that fee is correct, but it's documented that Dundee United had earlier turned down an offer of £400,000, so it could be true.

That's a lot of money, but he's 21 now and I can't see him featuring in the Premier League just yet... not sure what his future holds, but if it's away from Selhurst Park, I'd love to see him flying down the wing for us in League One.

 

I can see why Palace took a gamble on him but he's miles away from £500k, but given his now age and probably from a Premier League clubs perspective his lack of development on their scale, then perhaps a free transfer to us with huge beneficiaries their way if he comes good may be the way forward.

 

I know he's not our loan player anymore, but I reckon Tyreik Wright will be available next season, regardless of the division Plymouth are in. Thought it was a weird one at the time, not for the player as he'll be on a decent wage with a very good chance of promotion, but for the club.

They dont play with wingers, Wright is an out and out winger who can maybe play off a striker but he's a winger by trade. In his first few games before his injury, he seemingly played off the strikers to little effect and yesterday played as a left wing back...... he was getting destroyed on twitter by the Plymouth fans yesterday for his performance, a lot commenting that they never want to see him play again. Is he at the level for a championship chasing team? Probably not. However, he is certainly not a wing back, cant see him ever being capable of that role. Seems so weird to me that they sign a young lad on the form of his career so far after his spell with us, only to start trying to play him in defence.

 

for me its Crichlow and Banks - if we we can get Crichlow on a free thats the deal of the century.

What's really interesting to note is that both players contracts are up in the summer - Crichlows has an option to extend from town. https://www.htafc.com/news/2021/july/new-contracts-for-rowe--crichlow/

with the pair both being under 21 while at those clubs I expect us to pay a fee for both either way. but would be worth it!